back to Focal International home
  Back Issues

RUSSIAN BURIED TREAUSURE
A HIDDEN ARCHIVE, BUILT OVER THIRTY YEARS

By Evgueni Nagaitsev, Russian Producer, Researcher & Archivist


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

During 25 years of documentary films, I've researched more than 100 films and produced several educational films. I'm very familiar with the collections in the Russian State Archives, Krasnogorsk, Gosfilmofond, the TV and Radio Fund, the ministries, film studios and TV companies, including those located in the republics of the former Soviet Union.
When Lenin said: "The most important of all arts for us is cinematography," he was referring to the documentary films and newsreels that were bundled for audiences in propaganda-type communist wrapping.

Following the leader's legacy, dozens (during Stalin's times) and hundreds (during Brezhnev's times) of film studios and TV companies in all parts of the vast Soviet state, day after day, filmed communism's grandiose social construction site, shooting millions of metres of film.

When the Cold War ended, even this edifice became just another chapter in world history condemning thousands of newsreels to the archive shelves. It added to the huge archive brought to the USSR in 1946-1948, as a trophy from defeated Germany. This included not only German but also French, British, American, Polish, Czech, Italian, Hungarian films and newsreels. The Red Army also brought a valuable collection of Japanese and Chinese films and newsreels from Manchuria in 1945.

Among those topics on which I have worked using the materials of the Russian archives were the Civil War in Russia, the Gulag, the testing of Soviet rockets, leaders like Brezhnev, Gorbachev, Yeltsin, Kaiser Wilhelm, Hitler, Chang Kai Shek, Mao Tse Tung, Ho Chi Minh and Fidel Castro.

During these years I was collecting my own vast archive: more than 10,000 newsreels on 35 and 16 mm film and around 1,000 hours of footage on Betacam tapes. During communist times, one could copy kilometres of archive film from the state film archives: it was very cheap. For each project I worked on, I would copy much more material than was ever used, by a factor of tens or sometimes hundreds. Everyone was doing it at that time; the prices in the archives made it easier and cheaper to copy the full reels, rather than selected fragments. Some of the films, for which vast archive film material was selected and copied, were even never finished, for various reasons.

Collecting, not Burning

Back then it was the custom to destroy the archive materials that were not later included in the film, as well as the materials of the unfinished films. They were incinerated. While everyone was burning them, I was collecting. I also managed to obtain and preserve in my archive extreme material even on other projects, where friends or colleagues were working and could pass material on.

In the vast output of the time, the circulation of each film involved hundreds of copies, sent all over the country to be shown in cinemas, clubs and Houses of Culture, at schools, universities and military camps, in the pioneer camps, in the recreation facilities and even on the long distance ships. Before screening a feature film, every venue had to play either a newsreel or a short documentary even though audiences preferred comedies and melodramas and didn't want newsreels crammed with propaganda. Projectionists knew this and tried to indulge the viewers' tastes so many copies of these films were never shown; they were perfectly preserved, even better than copies of the same films kept in the state archives! At the beginning of the 90s when the system of the Soviet film distribution crashed with the empire, I saved hundreds of such films from destruction.

I spent all my earnings expanding my collection of documentaries and newsreels, though I can't say the cost was too high. Once, I bought a whole collection of films -- several dozen titles -- from one former director of a cinema, for ten bottles of vodka. He had to free up some storage space as soon as possible because the place was being converted to a furniture showroom. Others would even give the films away. I saved them from the need to dispose of them.

The problem with this plan was that I had to choose between an unexpected opportunity to enlarge my collection and the need to earn money to feed my family. Luckily, the most valuable part of my collection, I received as an inheritance. Actually, this legacy determined my fate as a collector and researcher of archive film. My maternal grandfather was the owner of a small film distribution company in the Far East of Russia where the Soviets came to power only in 1922.

New Econimic Politics

At that time Russia was going through the New Economic Politics (NEP) and small entrepreneurs in Khabarovsk, Vladivostok, Blagoveshensk, Nikolsk-Ussuriysk were lucky to escape the Bolshevist nationalisation and TcheKa requisitions which had rolled through most of the country in 1918. This distributor stayed as a private concern until 1929, when my grandfather had to "voluntarily" sign ownership over to the state. He stayed as technical director until 1935, when he was forced to leave everything behind and flee to Omsk in Siberia with my grandmother, who by that time already had five children. A friend -- who worked in NKVD -- warned him that they were going to come for him that night.

The family had occupied a two-storey house: the first floor was the offices, the second the living quarters for the family; the films were kept in the dry and cool stone cellar. In 1932, the Soviet authorities had built a large new cinema in the town to show October and Battleship Potemkin together with other new Bolshevik films. As the offices of the new nationalised film distribution company were also transferred into the theatre, the huge basement of the cinema was equipped for film storage. New "masterpieces" were to be kept there, while the old "rubbish"nobody needed anymore remained in my grandfather's cellar. There amazingly, it still is, several thousand reels of well preserved films of the pre-revolutionary Russia and Soviet films of 1920s, including feature films and newsreels that are not now available from the state archives.

Before my grandfather fled to Omsk city, his younger unmarried sister had lived with his family. An invalid since her childhood, her left foot dislocated, she was seriously lame. She was no threat to the Soviets so she was graciously allowed to live in the cellar and work as a cleaning lady in the offices upstairs. Yet when she died in 1993 at the age of 97, sound of mind with a clear memory, she had preserved and transferred to me my grandfather's heritage. He meanwhile, had perished in 1943 in the concentration camps.

In 1939, when Beria became NKVD Chief, the so-called "indulgence" had been arranged. Some people were released from the camps and allowed to return from exile. My grandfather decided to resettle in his hometown with his family. The film distribution company then hired him as a technician and it's possible that one of his duties, besides repairing the projector, was destroying films. How else to explain how several hundreds of boxes full of films of the 1930s, containing shots of "enemies of the people", were later found in the cellar? After his return from Omsk my grandfather lived for only one more year in freedom, for in 1940 he was arrested. In 1943, a notification came of his death in the camp. By now Grandmother was labouring to raise seven children, one of whom was my mother.

On my father's side, my grandfather was a peasant from Altai, drafted during World War 1 and promoted to officer for heroism at the front. The Civil War ended for him in Vladivostok in 1922, when he'd made it to lieutenant colonel.

Study of Cinematography

My father followed his lead and earned his epaulets with his blood during World War II, though he retired from the army after the War. Never as successful a military man as he would have liked, after my mother's death, he sent me to the Suvorov military school… in reality, Stalin's cadet corps for children between 11 and 18. However, despite being a top cadet, I never became an officer. Instead, as our family council had decided to entrust the grandfather's collection to me, I went for a more humanitarian education which included the study of cinematography. In 1967, I came to Moscow and entered the VGIK.

Today I still cannot name the place where the main -- and most precious -- portion of my collection is located. I am not certain that the state which killed my grandfathers and deprived my parents of their right to receive an education, condemning my family to poverty and stripping them of all their rights, would not try to seize my material. In legal terms, according to the Russian Law on Copyright of 1993 and the 1994 Civil Code, I am the rightful owner with every right to use it freely. However, I cannot forget the fact that in Russia, where the bureaucracy always stood and still stands, above the law; it can crush anyone at any time.

There are a lot of problems. Even the footage that I keep in Moscow has been only partially viewed and the computer database covers just a third of all material. Though it's gradually expanding; the collection is growing even faster. The Far Eastern part of the collection has practically not been catalogued yet. Yet to save it, I bought the house that once belonged to our family and now my relatives live in it. For me, this is a guarantee that some local authorities or bandits cannot gain access to the cellar where the films are stored, to create a slot machine arcade or vodka bottling facility. Of course, this is a temporary solution. The collection has to be moved to Moscow. While it is stored in the Far East, it remains useless to me. There's not even a film-to-video transfer facility available to record all the film archive to Betacam tapes using professional equipment.

I do not know if I will ever manage to solve this problem and gather all my archive in one place under one roof … I want to believe

Evgueni Nagaitsev, Russian Producer, Researcher & Archivist

First published, Autumn, 2000

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Email: enagaitsev@kaleidoarchive.com